In short: Your financial statements are always your responsibility, even when your auditor helped prepare them. An auditor cannot force you to book an adjustment, but can qualify the audit opinion if you refuse. You do not have to use your parent company’s auditor unless group policy says so, but it can be cheaper for the group overall. And paying the audit fee does not buy a clean opinion.
Written by Muhammad Sohail, CEO and Managing Partner at Alif Accounting & Tax Consultants, from his own experience in audit.
Companies are very watchful when it comes to the audit of their financial statements. How should we deal with our auditors? Do they know everything? Should we listen to them? Can they force us to do something we don’t want?
The relationship between a client and an auditor is delicate, and sometimes both sides simply don’t know what they can afford to do or say to each other. As many audit-related questions arrive in my mailbox, I have dedicated this article to the three biggest dilemmas you may face during the audit of your financial statements.
Please bear in mind that the answer is never a clear yes or no, black or white. Life is full of colours.
A note before we start: throughout this article I avoid professional audit terminology and I don’t cite professional rules or guidelines such as the International Standards on Auditing (ISAs). This is my opinion, based on my own experience. I hope you have some fun reading it, too.
1. Can we rely on financial statements prepared by our auditor?
In short, yes, you can, because auditors know what they are doing (in most cases) and they issue their audit opinion on those financial statements.
But auditors should not prepare your financial statements. Preparing them is your responsibility. The auditor’s task is to examine them, verify them and issue an opinion in the audit report.
Officially, no auditor can audit their own work. An auditor must be independent. In practice, that means you cannot hire one firm to prepare your financial statements (or even keep your books) and the same firm to audit them.
What about the situation where the auditor takes your trial balance and prepares the statement of financial position, the statement of comprehensive income, the cash flow statement and so on? In an ideal world, this should not happen. It is the audited company that should do it, not the auditor. In the real world, it happens a lot.
When I worked as an audit assistant, I remember preparing many cash flow statements (the biggest nightmare for most clients), notes to the financial statements and other components instead of my clients. The main reasons were:
- I did not need to wait for the client to prepare them;
- I did not have to search for errors, differences, balancing figures and unexplained numbers; and
- we saved a lot of time and effort.
Of course, the auditor’s name will never appear on the financial statements as the “author”, because of independence. Just remember that even when auditors draft the financial statements for you, you are still responsible for them.
2. Can our auditor force us to book something we don’t want?
In short, no, they cannot. The auditor does not keep your books, so it is not the auditor’s job to make you book anything. Don’t worry, no auditor will hold a knife to your neck.
But the auditor’s task is to express an opinion on what you have booked. If the auditor disagrees with your entries, for whatever reason, they will propose adjustments. There are then three basic scenarios:
- You accept the proposed adjustments and book them. The auditor issues a clean (unqualified) audit report.
- You support your numbers with arguments, additional information, estimates or calculations. If you are persuasive enough, the auditor may accept them and issue a clean opinion.
- You refuse to book the adjustments and leave the books as they are. The auditor issues a qualified opinion.
And, of course, something in between.
A real example
I was an audit senior at the time, auditing a company whose core business was machines for recharging mobile phone credit.
Say you want to top up your credit, so you pay FC 50 into the machine. Our client received FC 50 through the machine and had to pay FC 48 to the mobile operator. Our client’s real revenue was FC 2, the commission for facilitating the sale.
The client, however, recognised revenue of FC 50 and cost of sales of FC 48. Wrong. When you assess the agent and principal relationship, the company was only an agent arranging the sale. It was the mobile operator that provided the service to the end customer. The correct accounting was revenue of FC 2 and a payable of FC 48.
Why does it matter, when the profit is FC 2 either way? It makes a huge difference. The client had loans with a covenant to maintain a certain level of revenue. Revenue of FC 50 per transaction met the covenant; revenue of FC 2 did not. On top of that, management bonuses were based on revenue, not profit. You can do the maths, and you can imagine the fight.
We strongly disagreed with the numbers, but we could not force the client to correct them. The client refused to book the adjustment, and we issued a qualified opinion. This can happen to you, too.
3. Do we need to hire the same auditor as our parent company?
In short, no, unless your shareholder or group policy requires it.
But it can be more practical and cost-effective from the group’s point of view.
I understand very well why a small local branch of a multinational group wants a local audit firm rather than a Big Four firm. A Big Four firm can cost much more. However, think about it from the parent’s point of view.
The parent’s auditor has to audit the consolidated financial statements, so it also needs assurance over the subsidiaries’ financial statements. In practice, auditors often rely on the work of others, including other auditors.
If the subsidiary is audited by the same network (for example, the local office of the same Big Four firm), the parent’s auditor can usually rely on that work, because it follows the same audit procedures, policies and training. If the subsidiary is audited by a local firm, the parent’s auditor has to decide whether it can rely on that audit. In some cases it will perform its own audit of the subsidiary, which can be more expensive in total, because:
- the subsidiary pays an audit fee to its local auditor; and
- the parent pays an extra fee to the group auditor to re-perform the audit of the subsidiary.
So what can you do?
If your company is part of a group and you are choosing between a more expensive group auditor and a cheaper local auditor, think about the group’s materiality level. Is your local company big enough to cause a material error in the consolidated financial statements? If yes, the group auditor may be worth it. If your company is the size of a “rounding difference” in the group’s numbers, leave it to the local auditor.
Bonus: we pay the audit fee, so the opinion should be what we want?
I am not joking: this was a real request from a real client.
I had just been promoted to audit senior and was on my first engagement in the new role. It was a trial by fire. There was a mess everywhere I looked. Even the trial balance did not balance, and even the coffee was terrible.
At the final meeting, we told the client that, based on what we had seen, the report could not be clean. He looked at me and said: “I pay you the audit fee. You have to issue a clean report, because that’s what I pay for!” He meant it.
Now, seriously. The client pays the audit fee for the auditor to examine the financial statements and express an independent opinion. An independent opinion is not an opinion in line with the client’s wishes. That would not be independent.
I know, it sounds like a contradiction. How can an auditor be independent of a client who pays the fee? That is a fair question, which is exactly why there is a whole body of rules on auditor independence. Nothing is perfect. And apart from issuing the audit report, a good auditor is also there to help you, with sound advice on your accounting.
Frequently asked questions
Who is responsible for the financial statements, the company or the auditor?
The company. Management prepares the financial statements and is responsible for them, even if the auditor helped draft them. The auditor gives an opinion on them.
Can an auditor make us book an adjustment?
No. The auditor can propose adjustments. If you refuse and the difference matters, the auditor can issue a qualified opinion instead of a clean one.
Can the same firm keep our books and audit them?
No. An auditor must be independent and cannot audit their own work.
Does a subsidiary have to use the group auditor?
Only if the shareholder or group policy requires it. It can still be cheaper for the group overall, depending on how material the subsidiary is to the consolidated accounts.
Get help from Alif
Alif is an accounting and tax firm in Dubai. Our accounting team can prepare audit-ready books and financial statements, so your audit runs faster and with fewer surprises. Book a free consultation to discuss your position.



